This is easy. Trust me. I want to have a socratic dialogue about this question: "What really is nationalism, and is there anything inherently 'wrong' with nationalism?"
Your task:
1--Respond to the question and participate in the "discussion". Be sure to read ALL comments to this question that exist just before you comment, and respond to them as well.
2--Comment at least TWICE before 10:00, with a minimum response of 40 words per comment.
You are encouraged to :
A--Seek to define the dimensions of nationalism, using information from our class, other History classes, and/or online sources.
B--Ask QUESTIONS (related to the topic) for others to respond to.
C--Feel free to post links, quotes, or find creative ways to illustrate your point (using examples from USA or other places/time periods).
D--Continue to be respectful, academic, and "socratic" in your comments.
p.s. There is now a chance I will be in school tomorrow. Don't act TOO disappointed if you see me there, or I might get sad.
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
33 comments:
In your opinion at what point does nationalism become ethnic ostracism? When is it too much?
Ok honestly it didn't occur to me that maybe I should put my answer within my comment to actually get to the 40 required. I think that nationalism is a necessary evil to an extent. We need to identify with people, we need to feel connected to someone else. A common culture can do that for us. I do not believe that nationalism is beneficial when it becomes discriminatory against a group of people. The most obvious example is of course what atrocities were committed towards the Jews during World War II. When a group themselves decides to separate themselves from the strata of their country that is alright in my opinion, just kind of strange. The example we had in class today of Marcus Garvey's movement of people back to Africa struck me as offbeat. Yes those people who went back to Africa were black but they were in all intensive purposes AMERICAN. They had never been to Africa and had forgotten about their actual heritage. I do not call myself a European American, I call myself American, because I'm from here, not Europe.
Nationalism is not always a bad thing until is actually does become too much. I think it becomes too much when a person becomes one-minded about their Nationalism. It's ridiculous for a person to care only about their country and to hate everything else.
I agree with everything Julianne said about nationalism being beneficial until it becomes a problem for other races.
IRISH-AMERICAN HOUA! (member of the Irish Nation)
Okay first off, I would like to say that that today or yesterday in class me, Julianne, and Brian had a conversation about this because I thought that patriotism and nationalism is was the same thing. I totally agree with Julianne, nationalism is good until it comes to the point of discrimination. I believe nationalism should definitely be more about inclusion and connections than shutting others out completely. Oh and the red scare in the US with the Asians being put in “concentration camps”…would that be an example of nationalism in a sense because we were trying to protect “Americans” from bad “outsiders” in a sense. I still kind of think that nationalism and patriotism goes hand-in-hand. Maybe patriotism DEVELOPES into nationalism?
My question is how can we be patriotic "nationalistic" in the U.S. when we as a people do not know who and what we all are because we are so diverse. I do believe nationalism can create good things, but as we have seen in the past and today it cause irreparable harm to those we can not associate with. Even with in our nation we fight against each other because we, in our minds, do not accept our neighbors if they are different from us.
Well isn't our diversity what defines us as Americans? We can still be nationalistic even if we all have our own idiosyncrasies. Our differences do not keep us from being supportive of our nation. The very idea of nationalism itself should in fact keep us from isolating a specific group of people, but that doesn't always happen in real life. It's kind of like getting a hair cut, it's nice in theory but it never looks like it should on you. A great example of what Desiree is talking about with non-acceptance of people is the way Muslims were treated after September 11. As soon as I mentioned it I instantly felt like Rudy Giuliani.
I agree with Julianne that our diversity is what defines an "American" because we find pride in the fact that we are, indeed, a "melting pot" and through this melting pot we are more fair to all people and allow more freedoms and it makes us feel prideful. Okay so maybe that might have been a jump but it makes sense to me. I do understand where you are coming from though Desiree however I believe we SHOULD all have individual identities within our "nation" as julianne stated. One common shared tradition, language, or custom will make us a nation. Although we don't ALL have that I think we are united as a nation under democracy and our "freedoms".
I think Nationalism is good to a certain extent. I think people should have pride for where they came from and what it took to get them there. One of the most recent outburst of nationalism came after 9/11. America was so proud of what they stood for and all of a sudden all you see if red white and blue. While its good to have pride in one's country, I think there are times when people take it overboard. I think thats when it crosses the line and it is no longer good. When nationalism becomes racism because they are not the same as you it becomes a problem.
I agree with Julianne on the issue. We need nationalism until it becomes discriminatory...then it crosses the line
I have to agree on the diversity thing. America is like the mixing pot of every culture. Being apart of such a diverse nation is pretty much what makes us American. Our ability to accept others as our "brothers" in the land (that is excluding the psychotic racial citizens we tend to have in some areas) is in fact what brings us all together.
I think that nationalism is something the nation needs to an extent. You have to have a belief in your nation and want the nation to proceed and be united together.
But, once the nationalism turns into "our country will pwn your country ANY day."
and then theres the whole
"oh no you didnt"
due to the extreme nationalists on the other end.
and then a massive cat fight happens.
Which can lead to serious war, over dumbness.
So, yeah. Nationalism is good, to a point. But once it crosses that fine line into almost obsessive love for your country, no good!
Julianne said it perfectly.
Huzzah!
I don't think any of us have the authority to say if nationalism is "right" or "wrong," really. In the context of the modern world of nation-states, I think it is necessary, possibly a necessary evil as Julianne said. I’m not actually sure if you NEED a uniting language to create a sense of nationalism. Look at the European Union; now it’s practically a federal government. Europe has one of the most diverse language pools in the world.
I the one thing I find wrong about our country is that we say everyone is accept for being different but it isn't true. I every where I look I see racism. And Ashly I don't consider the full aggression of fighting back a form of nationalism . In fact I believe that if we were truly nationalistic then we would have understood that most muslins where not apart of the trade towers incident and would not have attacked our neighbor. The fact that we put all muslins in to one category goes against everything we believe. And this gets me back to my first point of how can we claim to be nationalistic when we don't recognize, understand and accept each others' differences because of this we attack those we claim are apart of us. I guess I'm so angry about this because of my aunt Dottie being Muslim and because she's dark skinned and have dark brown hair, and was married to a man from the middle east was counted among those who attack the Trade Towers in 2001. And to this day there are those out there who still don't trust her because of the stigmatism placed Middle Eastern Muslims from that event.
I always thought that Patriotism was Nationalism also and I'm pretty sure it goes hand in hand. Patriotism is the love of a country and thats basically what Nationalism is right?
We can be nationalistic, but still have certain identities about our culture
My family come from Puerto Rico, so my culture is, i guess,Puerto Rican, but I'm still American. My mom was born in Puerto Rico, so does that not make her an American?
I agree that diversity is what makes up this country.
i think the whole thing with your Aunt is more racism and stereotyping than nationalism.
People weren't really like "Oh our nation is superior to all others" after 9-11. It was more like "OH MY GOD WHAT JUST HAPPENED."
We didn't have much to rejoice about. However, people turned it into a "hey were in America we can stand together through this because were American and we have the ability united we stand blahblahblah"
So I guess a surge of nationalism was the aftermath maybe?
But the personal attacks on your Aunt were probably more of racism and such.
And not all Americans treated Muslims like crap afterwards. Some did, yeah, but I almost understand why. They were just driven by fear.
i see julianne is quite the popular one on the comment discussion tonight.
Nationalism is the love for one's country, the pride in one's heritage, the complete dedication to one's country. I think nationalism is important. You have to be proud of who you are and what you stand for. Being nationalistic doesn't mean you can't be your own individual. This goes with the diversity conversation happening. America is very diverse, but yet we are all still connected in our love for our country and it's freedoms. good ol' American Pride.
As a response to megan and dessi's convo. Just because we are diverse doesn't mean the diversities are what we accept as one. We are connected by our patriotism not our differences, obviously..right? so therefore nationalism and racism are completely different topics...right?
please feel free to tell me to be quiet if i make no sense. haha.
Isn't it interesting that right after 9-11 there was the huge surge of nationalism? Where has it gone now? After it occurred everyone had an American flag on their car. Now they're no where to be seen. It takes a major event for everyone in the country to unite and then people just .........
Julianne. you have a good point.
It can almost be seen as the opposite now. People are getting fed up with the whole Iraq situation and actually are not supporting the decisions made by our government. Right after 9-11 americans felt connected and joined in the belief that we must protect our people and our country. But now all they see is America attacking another country and no results. So maybe this is causing the nationalism and patriotism to decrease. I guess in a world of perfect nationalism, America should never question an act that is meant to protect. America should support all decisions made by their government and leaders.
and i realize i didn't answer all the questions in my last comment..the required ones..
i would say nationalism could be "bad" for all the reasons discussed in the comments thus far. But you have to think, these people performing these acts wouldn't see the bad in "nationalism" instead all the feel is the surge of pride in who they are and what they are working for/towards. So i guess nationalism is "bad" because it can be blinding...
I think Julianne has pointed out something that I’ve been concerned about for a long time. Obviously, there is a lot of anti-American sentiment abroad, but I think there is a growing disaffection within America as well. We’re losing a sense of UNIFIED nationalism because our culture has grown so divisive. Our definition of nationalism varies depending on perspective, or seemingly where you buy your coffee. We’re resorted to petty politics, e.g., “Shame on you, Obama,” and corporate control. At this point I’m thinking of voting for Nader, almost.
Beth said the other day that she loved America because we are free to have our opinions.
I agree with her. I love that, but our nationalism has slowly taken a turn for nativism and racism. I don’t know. Right now I’m kind of disappointed in America. This election of “change” has slowly transformed into more mud slinging and ignoring of the issues.
Shame on you, politicians; and shame on you, Americans, for letting it get this far.
Sorry for the tangent? But I feel it's relevant.....
When did elections stop being about actual POLITICS? Policy and actions seem more important to me then who did what or wore what when. When did this
http://wwwimage.cbsnews.com/images/2008/02/25/image3876027.jpg
become something that could be important in an election? Honestly he was just wearing clothing from another culture. People's intolerance is debilitating. I just thought I would post this really quick in response to Brian's lovely comment.
desi i wasnt saying that the fighting back with iraq was nationalism. I was saying that after 9/11 there was a burst of nationalism throughout our country. Everyone was standing together. The fighting is a completely different topic. The people and how they reacted as a nation was nationalism. The attack on your aunt was more of racism which also was apart of the aftermath of 9/11 but not what i was getting at with my example of nationalism.
I also agree that patriotism and nationalism go hand in hand to a certain degree. They are both a love of ones country so they must have some connection.
Nationalism can be tricky i think. I dont think a lot of people understand the difference between nationalism and racism. But i could be wrong. Some people do take up nationalism as hatred for everything different...but i dont see it that way. I think it means having a united pride in your country and what it took for you to get where you are today....but not without an appreciation for others. This is just my opinion which could be wrong
ashley. i completely agree with your last few statements.
Nowhere in the "definition" of nationalism does it say you must hate everyone but your own. You may believe your country is the "best" but you can be nationalistic and still appreciate what other countries have gone through, and what they stand for...or at least in most cases..sometimes, (the holocaust) we may not find it in us to appreciate their actions and love for their country. if you can even call that love for a country..
anyways. go ashley! ha..
i think i am going to go with the flow tonight.
i also agree with julianne.nationalism can be evil or good. you have to look at the way it is being used. everyone has a thought. But as dessi was saying. i dont really think there is racism in nationalism. if there was nationalism, then there wouldn't be racism,
and vice versa. i agree with ashley how there was a big outburst of nationalism when 9/11 came to be. to me personally it seems that we, americans, always need a event or something like this to encourage nationalism. Why? maybe it is because we are so use to others saying that the US had a lot of nationaliam,back during the independence and such, that now we forget that we dont have that anymore. it seems as if people have forgotten what we had to do to get what we have today and what we did do included nationalism, but now that we are justsitting around surfing the web, we dont think about it as much. it
seems as if we are so ready to just take the freedom that we won, through our forefathers who were true nationalism, for granted. so we dont see what we are lacking and we dont see that there is no nationalism. maybe after 9/11 that wasnt even nationalism. maybe it was just a problem that arose that gave americans a chance to think they had nationalism and so that just grasp what they could.If what we had was real nationalism we would still have that right now even though the event has passed us by.
I kow I'm late inn this coversation but I agree with brian's first comment. For me I don't beleive that nationalism is a concept that can be tied to just one specific culture. For example me... I totally love my birth country of Mexico and support it in any way ( soccer, olmpics, FOOD!), but in the other hand I consider the United States to be my home too and support them at times as much as I support Mexico... If I were really really asked what I considered myself i would like to say that I am both Mexican and American...When does nationalism play into the fact that our world today is constantly changing its values, concerns, and ethnic characteristics?
Ok so catching up with this conversation I have to agree with everyone because nationalism is what you make it be... If you in your mind and soul believe what you want to believe than no matter what it will always be true for you and so is nationalism...Once you define what you are and what/who you stand for than nationalism begins... There was noone who went around the world and told different groups what made them unique It just developed....
As to 9/11 I would like to think that America had a resurgence of nationalism but I could not be that naive... Ever since the end of World War II we have been the world's police... sure we had internal problems but I can't think of an accident where an outsider delibarately hurtour motherland... But when 9/11 happened I think it became a shock to us that the WORLD'S police, the protector of this world, was unable to defend its own self... i think that the sense of patriotism that surged after this tragedy was more to reassure our selves more than the rest of the world as a defense mechanism... We needed to know that there was hope instead of promoting our nationalistic power to the rest of the world
I also believe that it is great that America is diverse... Our diversity is what makes our nation unique because it is able to promote nationalism not through an ethnic group but though an ideal (freedom, self opportunity, etc)
that is very true melissa. i agree that we do see it as a defense mechanism. we dont know what else to do, so we bring out the patriotism to give ourselves hope. then as soon as the problem is forgotten, not totally forgotten but in the back of our minds, then we kind of drift away from it.
I was impressed by this dialogue, and I think that you raised some interesting questions and issues that get at the problematic nature of studying this thing called "nationalism."
If I may, I would like to paraphrase and isolate some of the (many) important questions/ideas that you raised. I've separated them into "3 Questions" that many of your comments seem to speak to.
QUESTION #1: Is NATIONALISM any different from PATRIOTISM or UNITY?
Liz -- "Nationalism is the love for one's country, the pride in one's heritage, the complete dedication to one's country. I think nationalism is important. You have to be proud of who you are and what you stand for. Being nationalistic doesn't mean you can't be your own individual...America is very diverse, but yet we are all still connected in our love for our country and it's freedoms."
Julianne -- "I think that nationalism is a necessary evil to an extent. We need to identify with people, we need to feel connected to someone else. A common culture can do that for us. I do not believe that nationalism is beneficial when it becomes discriminatory against a group of people..."
Marie: "I thought that patriotism and nationalism is was the same thing...I believe nationalism should definitely be more about inclusion and connections than shutting others out."
Megan: "Nowhere in the 'definition' of nationalism does it say you must hate everyone but your own.
Desiree: "My question is how can we be patriotic 'nationalistic' in the U.S. when we as a people do not know who and what we all are because we are so diverse(?)"
Stephanie: "Patriotism is the love of a country and thats basically what Nationalism is right?
We can be nationalistic, but still have certain identities about our culture."
Question #2: Is NATIONALISM 'exclusivist'? Does it allow for DIVERSITY? How much diversity?
Julianne: "...(I)sn't our diversity what defines us as Americans? We can still be nationalistic even if we all have our own idiosyncrasies. Our differences do not keep us from being supportive of our nation. The very idea of nationalism itself should in fact keep us from isolating a specific group of people, but that doesn't always happen in real life." "...When a group themselves decides to separate themselves from the strata of their country that is alright in my opinion, just kind of strange.""
Ashley: "While its good to have pride in one's country...when nationalism becomes racism because (others) are not the same as you it becomes a problem."
Megan: "Being apart of such a diverse nation is pretty much what makes us American. Our ability to accept others as our "brothers" in the land is in fact what brings us all together."
Brian: "I don't think any of us have the authority to say if nationalism is "right" or "wrong," really. In the context of the modern world of nation-states, I think it is necessary, possibly a necessary evil as Julianne said...(Also), I’m not actually sure if you NEED a uniting language to create a sense of nationalism."
Melissa: I also believe that it is great that America is diverse... Our diversity is what makes our nation unique because it is able to promote nationalism not through an ethnic group but though an ideal (freedom, self opportunity, etc).
Question #3: Is the US truly NATIONALISTIC these days?
Brian: "...We’re losing a sense of UNIFIED nationalism because our culture has grown so divisive. Our definition of nationalism varies depending on perspective."
Ashley: "Nationalism can be tricky i think. I dont think a lot of people understand the difference between nationalism and racism... Some people do take up nationalism as hatred for everything different, but i dont see it that way. I think it means having a united pride in your country and what it took for you to get where you are today, but not without an appreciation for others."
Maineng: "I agree with ashley how there was a big outburst of nationalism when 9/11 came to be. to me personally it seems that we, americans, always need a event or something like this to encourage nationalism. Why? maybe it is because we are so use to others saying that the US had a lot of nationalism, back during the independence and such, that now we forget that we dont have that anymore. it seems as if people have forgotten what we had to do to get what we have today and what we did do included nationalism, but now that we are justsitting around surfing the web, we dont think about it as much. it
seems as if we are so ready to just take the freedom that we won, through our forefathers who were true nationalism, for granted. so we dont see what we are lacking and we dont see that there is no nationalism. maybe after 9/11 that wasnt even nationalism. maybe it was just a problem that arose that gave americans a chance to think they had nationalism and so that just grasp what they could.If what we had was real nationalism we would still have that right now even though the event has passed us by."
Melissa: "As to 9/11 I would like to think that America had a resurgence of nationalism but I could not be that naive... Ever since the end of World War II we have been the world's police... sure we had internal problems but I can't think of an accident where an outsider delibarately hurtour motherland... But when 9/11 happened I think it became a shock to us that the WORLD'S police, the protector of this world, was unable to defend its own self... i think that the sense of patriotism that surged after this tragedy was more to reassure our selves more than the rest of the world."
Nationalism has many different definitions according to my friends at dictionary.com. Some are moderate such as, "national spirit or aspirations," or "patriotism." Another definition included is, "excessive patriotism; chauvinism." One even includes a movement that inspires a nation based on historic origins. Nationalism has different meanings for different people. My connotation of nationalism is most closely identified with the pride in one's country definition. Not even necessarily country, but culture. The Cherokee Nation and other 'American Indian' tribes are American citizens, but the perserve their culture and are strongly nationalistic to it. For some people, they are patriotic to their religon. I'm trying to express that nationalism isn't a bad thing. The only negative things that could come from being proud of your nationality is when you feel a sense of superiority, and others get hurt, or devalued because of this.
Though we are a diverse class, I noticed that most everyone said something to the extent of nationalism being needed/ accepted/ good/ positive, but when it becomes, "extreme."
And to the Americans being nationalist because we are diverse, we still have things that unite the majority of us.
Sorry I'm posting this late... My mom kept me away from home until late Thursday night and i figured that it would be counted late (since it wasn't because of work), so I decided not to stress too super much about finishing the assignment late Thursday night...
so anyway, about the nationalism thing (yes, I actually read ALL of the millions of comments... lol)... I definitely agree that it can be good or bad (depending on just how radical the nationalism is). I believe that for the most part, nationalism is ok, until it infringes on the rights of or discriminates against another people group. In a sense, it is almost necessary to hold a nation together, since most nations are made up of a majority group - a group that shares a common heritage and culture. If a nation is full of nationalistic and patriotic citizens, then they are more willing to defend their people when they are threatened by an outide nation/group of people. But this nationalism should not be to the extent that the group of people are intolerant of others (outside of the predominant ethnicity) visiting/living in their nation.
I totally agree with Melissa. I had been trying to think of how we as Americans can have some sort of shared nationalism when we don't have a common heritage/ethnicity, and Melissa's comment made perfect sense. We as Americans come from the same background in the sense that we were all looking for freedom from repression, tyranny, and intolerance. Our ancestors wanted better opportunities for their families. And it is for reasons like those that almost all of our ancestors - whether Irish, German, Japanese, whatever - came to America. All of our ancestors had those qualities in common, and that is what gives Americans the chance to develop a sense of nationalism and patriotism.
Where was I for all this? 31 comments was alot to read!! But I do have to say that after reading these commetns made it so much easier to write my blog entry on nationalism. DARn!!
I am still confuse on what is Patriotism and Nationalism? I do agree with Maire that maybe Patriotiism leads into Nationalism. I mean it makes sense since nationalism is like the movement of making a unified state where its people share similar history and social traditions. So those who are natinalistic have pride for their country right? So would Hilter trying to be nationalistic too? ( out of no where :) How are we to deteremine when Nationalism is bad or good?
I also agree with Zack amd melissa about Natioanlism how it depends on the culture. I think each county views NAtionalis differently. We as americans are so differnt since we are so diverse so our Nationalism is soely based on our history. But other countires like Germany, they are unified because of their ethnicity. But that leaves us the question of does America have an ethnicity or will it soon develop one? Since the Germans could of been a certain race but throughout the years (hundres) evolutions happens and makes the people as we know "Germans". So if one day after so many years, will there be an American ethnicity too? (random)
Post a Comment