I was impressed by your dialogue about nationalism, and I think that you raised some interesting questions and issues that get at the problematic nature of studying this thing called "nationalism."
Below, I have isolated some of the (many) important questions/ideas that you all discussed in your posts. I've separated them into "3 Questions" that many of your comments seem to speak to. I also posted these at the bottom of the comments (on the previous post) in case you want to see them in their original context. Please read over all of these before doing the assignment.
THE ASSIGNMENT:
MAKE A NEW POST...an essay that answers one of the 3 questions below.
In your essay, be sure to do these things:
A--Answer all parts of the question with as SPECIFIC evidence and historical examples as possible (at least 300 words)
B--Include at least one reference to at least part of a definition of nationalism from a scholarly source.
C--Read over your classmates comments, and make reference to at least one person's comment in your post (more are encouraged)
D--Post a comment here when you are done (by 9:00 pm on Sunday night for full credit), and be sure to tell me: 1--which question you answered and 2--which of your classmates comments you spoke to in your post.
As usual, feel free to use the "multimedia" available to you in your post, as many of you often do -- video, links, articles, pictures, maps, etc. are all great if they help you get your point across.
Have a good weekend!
QUESTION #1: Is NATIONALISM any different from PATRIOTISM or UNITY?
How might the "nationalism" of German, Italian, or French people during the 19th century have been different for them than it is for Americans in the 21st century?
Question #2: Is NATIONALISM 'exclusivist'? Does it allow for DIVERSITY? How much diversity? How might German, Italian, or French people during the 19th century have dealt with the issue of DIVERSITY differently than we Americans do in the 21st century? How does your answer to these questions show that nationalism in 19th century Europe may have a different meaning that nationalism in 21st century U.S.
Question #3: Is the US truly NATIONALISTIC these days? Compare 21st century American nationalism to the nationalism of any 19th century country we have discussed or read about in class (including the readings from Friday).
QUESTION #1: Is NATIONALISM any different from PATRIOTISM or UNITY?
Liz -- "Nationalism is the love for one's country, the pride in one's heritage, the complete dedication to one's country. I think nationalism is important. You have to be proud of who you are and what you stand for. Being nationalistic doesn't mean you can't be your own individual...America is very diverse, but yet we are all still connected in our love for our country and it's freedoms."
Julianne -- "I think that nationalism is a necessary evil to an extent. We need to identify with people, we need to feel connected to someone else. A common culture can do that for us. I do not believe that nationalism is beneficial when it becomes discriminatory against a group of people..."
Marie: "I thought that patriotism and nationalism is was the same thing...I believe nationalism should definitely be more about inclusion and connections than shutting others out."
Megan: "Nowhere in the 'definition' of nationalism does it say you must hate everyone but your own.
Desiree: "My question is how can we be patriotic 'nationalistic' in the U.S. when we as a people do not know who and what we all are because we are so diverse(?)"
Stephanie: "Patriotism is the love of a country and thats basically what Nationalism is right?
We can be nationalistic, but still have certain identities about our culture."
Question #2: Is NATIONALISM 'exclusivist'? Does it allow for DIVERSITY? How much diversity?
Julianne: "...(I)sn't our diversity what defines us as Americans? We can still be nationalistic even if we all have our own idiosyncrasies. Our differences do not keep us from being supportive of our nation. The very idea of nationalism itself should in fact keep us from isolating a specific group of people, but that doesn't always happen in real life." "...When a group themselves decides to separate themselves from the strata of their country that is alright in my opinion, just kind of strange.""
Ashley: "While its good to have pride in one's country...when nationalism becomes racism because (others) are not the same as you it becomes a problem."
Megan: "Being apart of such a diverse nation is pretty much what makes us American. Our ability to accept others as our "brothers" in the land is in fact what brings us all together."
Brian: "I don't think any of us have the authority to say if nationalism is "right" or "wrong," really. In the context of the modern world of nation-states, I think it is necessary, possibly a necessary evil as Julianne said...(Also), I’m not actually sure if you NEED a uniting language to create a sense of nationalism."
Melissa: I also believe that it is great that America is diverse... Our diversity is what makes our nation unique because it is able to promote nationalism not through an ethnic group but though an ideal (freedom, self opportunity, etc).
Question #3: Is the US truly NATIONALISTIC these days?
Brian: "...We’re losing a sense of UNIFIED nationalism because our culture has grown so divisive. Our definition of nationalism varies depending on perspective."
Ashley: "Nationalism can be tricky i think. I dont think a lot of people understand the difference between nationalism and racism... Some people do take up nationalism as hatred for everything different, but i dont see it that way. I think it means having a united pride in your country and what it took for you to get where you are today, but not without an appreciation for others."
Maineng: "I agree with ashley how there was a big outburst of nationalism when 9/11 came to be. to me personally it seems that we, americans, always need a event or something like this to encourage nationalism. Why? maybe it is because we are so use to others saying that the US had a lot of nationalism, back during the independence and such, that now we forget that we dont have that anymore. it seems as if people have forgotten what we had to do to get what we have today and what we did do included nationalism, but now that we are justsitting around surfing the web, we dont think about it as much. it
seems as if we are so ready to just take the freedom that we won, through our forefathers who were true nationalism, for granted. so we dont see what we are lacking and we dont see that there is no nationalism. maybe after 9/11 that wasnt even nationalism. maybe it was just a problem that arose that gave americans a chance to think they had nationalism and so that just grasp what they could.If what we had was real nationalism we would still have that right now even though the event has passed us by."
Melissa: "As to 9/11 I would like to think that America had a resurgence of nationalism but I could not be that naive... Ever since the end of World War II we have been the world's police... sure we had internal problems but I can't think of an accident where an outsider delibarately hurtour motherland... But when 9/11 happened I think it became a shock to us that the WORLD'S police, the protector of this world, was unable to defend its own self... i think that the sense of patriotism that surged after this tragedy was more to reassure our selves more than the rest of the world."
Saturday, March 1, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
19 comments:
By the way...major extra credit for anyone who goes to Verdi's La Traviata tonight at the Classic Center tonight in Athens and writes a post about it. It's the cheapest ticket for opera that I've ever seen. 20 bucks. 706 357 4444. GO!
Done.
and i think i did it right?
I hope.
it took forever
I didn't go to an opera, but I went and saw Persepolis? GIMME EXTRA CREDIT.
okay im also done.
got an early head start on it instead of rushing at the very last minute!
YAY!
i think this is a first for me.
;]
but i think its right. I did all the parts as bestd i knew how so yeah.
I did question #3 and commented on Ashley and Mings comments in my essay thingy.
I did question three and commented on Mings :D
Done!
I answered question 2 and discussed Padiller's comment.
See ya in class!
I'm finished! I answered question #2 and I used Ashley's comment!
Finished, and I referenced Melissa.
anddddddddd I did question # 3. sorry.
hello...i jsut wanted to tell you that i just got home form Myrtle beach...heehhehe
done. question 3. maineng's comment.
done.
i did question number one and referred to one of Julianne's comments.
=P
Done, Question 2 and Ashley. ~desi 8:52 pm Sunday
I fished, and used Maineng's and Melissa's comments.
Question #3 sorry i forgot
I did it..man oh man that was a very hard assignment. I hope i did it right?? I think i did a littl over board that's why it took me so long...sorry...
I did Ming and Brian and question number 3
this is ming. sorry i didnt post on time. i didnt look at the blog all weekend. i did mine on question #1 and hopefully did it right. i also used Julianne's and Melissa's comments.
forgot to tell you. we couldnt get a comp. so i will just start to do homework, whenever we have it, at a friends house until i can save up enough to get a laptop. i know, i was really disappointed. -_-
Post a Comment