For now, simply COMMENT HERE (not a post, a comment) with at least TWO attempts at analyzing "point of view" in your last essay. Next to each original attempt, you should write whether or not you got POV credit. You are also encouraged to include an attempt at revising the statements that did not get credit. You can also include questions (for me or anyone else in the class) that you may have about why your statements did/did not get credit.
Feel free to get advice from other students when doing this assignment.
This is due by 9:00 pm tonight, March 10th.
We will be discussing these in class to clarify all of your questions.
Monday, March 10, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
18 comments:
*As a foreigner living and seeing the conditions of Turkish rule Dallaway experienced firsthand how these classes interacted and compared (the Greeks) to their former glory. (credit)
1: The actually circumstances and conditions of the Greek are most likely unknown to Dallaway since he is a British resident and not a Greek.
2:(You said this was almost a POV, but I'm not sure why)
Being an educated scholar of Greek ugh the fights and has seen the and Arabic, Savary was able to make an observation about Turkey using his/her knowledge which means what he/she said was not out of spite, but rather intelligence.
3: Mavrocordetto has been throdestruction that this country has been through, which is probably why he is proud of his country and the people.
1.His view is so honest and trustworthy to all because he is not greek nor turkish.(re-word and ive got it but you will give it to me)
2.Her view is trustworthy since she is English rooting for the Greeks and had no reason other than careful watching to judge the war by. {Too Vague-cant get point for POV.0
ok so i have a question (this is about my handout)
We put all of our paintings on it and everything that you wanted and i put it on word and it was 15 pages long!!0_o
What do i do?
we need those pictures AND the info....ssssssssssssso0oo0o0o.....
????
1) The erudite Frenchman, Claude Savory, politely says that the Greeks are absused and inflicted with "injuries of every kind which they [Turks] have done to the sciences, the arts, and the human race." He wants Europe to get as riled as he, and free the Greeks.
2)The leader, and President of the Greek revolutionary government, Alexander Movrocardoto, hopes this government will keep Greece safe, the Church safe, and keep peace. He acknowledges the progress Greeks have made, but promises what he hopes will be a triumphant government.
Those were my only two.Thanks!
1. The Enlightenment brought new emphasis on the classics of Greek literature and this could have influenced this scholar's opinion.
(credit)
2. Being the president of the Greek revolutionary government, this individual would be supportive of the struggle against Turkish control.
("too obvious" to receive credit)
Here are the rest of my POV"s:
*As a revolutionnary and leader of Greece's new independent state he {Alexender Mavrocordato} could have been clouded as to the needs of others(foreign countries and Turks) to protect his country from the Turks.
*Some saw the Turks as intruders to a culture that had given (back)so much.
*As a Romantic writer Shelley's literature was influenced by classical literature of Grece.This fact could have provided amunition towards his respect for Greece.
1) Original:
Savary was a scholar specializing in Greek and Arabic so consequently he supported the Greeks' efforts.
(I did not receive credit for this.)
Revised:
The fact that Savary was a scholar educated in Greek and Arabic most likely skewed his views towards supporting the Greek cause because of his background in the field.
2) Original:
His outlook might have been influenced by his faith in God. Also Mavrocordato knew his followers would see this work, therefore he wanted to say something positive so they would not become dishearted.
I think I received credit for this? I'm not quite sure, there is a check in it's general vicinity.
But who said Alexander's word could be trusted because he is the president and had been in favor of the revolution so of course he would've had reasons for their fighting.
i didnt know what to put b/c you only marked at one section where you said i was atempting.
The Turkish Sultan, Mustapha III, described the greeks as "evildoers" and "brigands" in his orders to suppress Greek raids. As a Turkish Sultan he didn't see these raids as a fight for just cause, but instead might have viewed them as chaotic, annoying attempts to cause trouble.
(got credit)
As a loyalist to the Turks, Vahid would most likely not find any justice in the Greek cause.
(got credit)
1.)Kalphoglous expresses his belief that the Greeks aren't really Greeks, by those trying to impersonate the French and by doing so starting a revolution; revolution not for the Creeks but because it is what the French would do.
2.)Vahid Pasha wrote that the Greek revolution "was at the bottom the result of satanical and diabolical designs." Thus implying inplying the members of the revolution to be santanical. (could have put.. thus he thought.... because he had no wish of revolution and it was against the government he worked for as pasha... or some such)
Lateeeeeeeee
I thought this was due Friday because I'm stupid?
Excuse: I was "scanning it in word."
I'm kidding though.
1)The opinion that Greece's independence was rigteous, as displayed by Mavrocrodato, was prevalent throughout Greece and viewed by some as self-serving and (perhaps) convenient for the Greek political leaders (like Mavrocordato). (mcmaken)
2)His domineering manner may have been based in fact, or disillusionment as a result of Turkish despotism.
3)This French scholar elucidates the danger that Turks, who are commonly portrayed as ignorant, had damaged the secular accomplishments of the Greeks as well.
Sorry for turning it late (worK)...um..i thought we were supose to make a blog but now i realized that it was just a comment..but here it is:
1.)This source is gearing towards an opinion that has personal motive rahter than a neutral one. He state his views on the Greeks onlt based on how they drifted away form the chruch.
2.)Sultan's report may seem a little irrational since they wer the enemy of the Greeks. It only made sense if the Sultan would insult the behavior of the Greeks.
3.)James’ view on the Greek was possibly corrected since he was a foreigner, analyzing Greek's behavior and the change in their values. (bad one)
well crapola. Got home at 8:30 from drama practice and totes forgot. I'll do it in the morning for points off.
POV attempt 1: "The Greeks were even accused of using the religion of Christianity to promote their 'satanical causes and diabolical designs.' (Doc. 9) Vahid Pasha, the man who originated this claim, was a Turkish provincial governor, and it was probably within his best interest to deride and accuse the Greeks."
I got credit for that one.
POV attempt 2: "One of the greatest authorities on Greek culture at the time, Claude Savary, discusses the 'injuries of every kind which they [the Turks] have done to the sciences, the arts, and the human race..' in a letter. Savary's knowledge and eminence in Greek studies whould not be overlooked."
I didn't get credit for this one. Mr Mcmaken said "true, but how might what he studied influence his words?" I understand how I didn't get this one...
see you guys in class!
Oh, and it's late because of work -4-11 shift... :(
Post a Comment