Thursday, April 10, 2008

DBQ Essay A

What do you think this essay should get? Respond. Also, feel free to raise questions about parts of the essay (groups, thesis, POV analysis, analysis of documents, outside information, etc.) If you are responding to someone else's comment, be sure to make it clear who you are addressing.

14 comments:

Brian said...

I have DBQ Essay A a 6 total.
Although its phraseology is pretty...awkward, it does answer the question.

Megahertz said...

I have it at a 6 too. The POV there, the groups are there, the thesis, all of it.
It's just not .. exceptional.
and it's odd.


but it's there.

Padiller said...

I do thnk that this person got all the 6 points but didn't this essay also have more than 3 POV's?

Steph it up =] said...

I said that A got a 5, but it was really weird because i didn't see a thesis and alot of the P.O.V's weren't really P.O.V's

Marie said...

I gave this DBQ a 5 because it had a thesis, although I'm not sure it was really as explicit as I would have liked, because the whole first paragraph seemed like a Thesis. The point I didn't give was for interpretation because Doc 4 seemed to be completely off from from the grading guide said it should be used for. Otherwise it was a good essay.

Zabe Thompson said...

I would give it a 6 or 7. I feel the student answers the question, and analyzes the documents pretty well, making more three attempts at POV.

Ashley said...

I gave this essay a 5 also. I thought it used a lot of documents pretty well. This person also did a lot of pov attempts. I gave half a point for thesis because while i didnt think it was well developed, it nonetheless was a thesis.

Dissydesi said...

really I thought it did answer the question, my problem was wether or not if it had groups. It was hard for me to read the document but I could pick out 4 povs and9 document usages. so if it had groups I would give it a 7/8

Nick said...

I gave it a 6. He wasn't really eloquent in making his point but it is all there.

Anonymous said...

I gave this DBQ a 5. I found two documents that it misinterpreted - Documents 2 and 4. I felt like all the other criteria were there.

I'm not quite sure about the groups though.. I mean, I found three that seemed to be legitimate, but they weren't on the list of groups on the rubric... Can we approve a group that doesn't appear on the rubric?

Master Liz said...

I gave Essay A a score of 7.
It met all the requirements for the first 6 points and had an extra group.

Megahertz said...

Yeah Zack, you can. It says those groups "may" be used.

Implying there could be more :D

Pooh Bear said...

This DBQ i gave them a 5. It was pretty well written and though it wasn't that well written, everything was there. But i was not sure if the thesis was supported by the groupings. One of their groups was not mentioned int he thesis. I don't know...maybe i just read it wrong. i just want to know why they would get a 6.

Master Liz said...

pooh. it didn't matter that there was a group that wasn't mentioned in the thesis. The graders grade these based on whether the thesis ANSWERS THE DARN question and if the groups back that up. It says nothing about losing a point for having extra information..
i think..lol