Thursday, April 10, 2008

DBQ Essay B

What do you think this essay should get? Respond. Also, feel free to raise questions about parts of the essay (groups, thesis, POV analysis, analysis of documents, outside information, etc.) If you are responding to someone else's comment, be sure to make it clear who you are addressing.

16 comments:

Brian said...

I gave DBQ Essay B a 3. The writer exhausted themselves by using every single source possible, but neglected the actual question. The thesis presented answers what role sports play, but not how Europeans PERCEIVED this role. The student had no POVs, which further convinces me that this essay was not written about viewpoint, but sports' role, not how Europeans perecieved this role.

Megahertz said...

I gave essay B a five.
I see where Brian's coming from, but I see how they thought saying it was a "positive development" was how it was perceived. The main thing I don't see in the essay is POV. Like, anywhere.
They answereed their thesis, but I can see where the question would be arised as if their thesis actually answers the question.

Padiller said...

I agree with Megan. I see were the "positive development" would be how people reacted to it. THe only thing I did not see in this essay was POV. I gave this essay a 5 too

Ashley said...

I also gave essay B a 5. I thought it had a pretty well developed thesis. But like everyone else has stated this essay contained no POV attempts at all and that will hurt a grade.

Marie said...

I gave this DBQ a 5 because it had an explicit thesis "The impacts of organized sports on Europe was a positive development which furthered nationalist patriotism through unification, encouraged morality, physical health, fostered a sense of comradery and furthered women's rights, and created a new bond between countires." which I think explicitly answers the question. However, I found no P.O.V. in this document.

Dissydesi said...

I gave this a 3 as well because it had groups and a thesis, but there where no povs that I could find. The fact that they used 11 coduments doesn't make up for the lack of povs. It doesn't meet the reagular guidelines so it can't get a five.

Steph it up =] said...

When i read the first paragraph i saw that it was kind of tied in because to everything they said about how it "encouraged morality and physical health, and fostered a sense of comradery". The person did use most of the documents, but did go around the question. This essay has a lot of information from the documents, but doesn't fully answer the question. I also saw no P.O.V's so i gave this person a 4

Pooh Bear said...

This essay was so hard to read. I felt that they did exhaust themselves with all the documents and stuff. Um..the thesis was so messy. I thought that it needed to be revised because the groups was hard to find. This person did get the groupings but the thesis weakend the essay with all the scattered thoughts..i just got really confused...but i did them a 4 or 5..other than the thesis it was good and meet the requirements..

Brian said...

I just think it's difficult to explore perception without the incorporation point-of-view.

For example, the thesis says that sports "developed the equality of women."

We can say, for instance, that slaves were abolished in the 19th century, but this does not say how Americans PERCEIVED this event. The thesis presents facts, not opinions or perceptions.

That's what I think.

Anonymous said...

I gave this DBQ a 4. I completely agree with Brian about the thesis thing. The writer addressed the impact sports had on European society, but didn't really explicitly state the different ways sports were perceived in the thesis.

And I may be crazy, but I didn't find a single POV (or even an attempt at one)...

Those were the only two points I counted off for them (Thesis and POVs)

Master Liz said...

I gave this essay a score of five.
I felt that the only thing it lacked was POV..which by the way i couldn't even find one attempt??

It did answer the question and used numorous groups and almost all of the documents to back it up.

Brian said...

Megan and Melissa:

I think the "positive developement" is the opinion of the author.

Unless he's European, it doesn't answer the question to me.


He'd also have to be alive from 1860-1940.

Marie and I just had that discussion.

Nick said...

I gave it a 4 because of lack of POVs, and I don't think the thesis answers the question; it just says what impacts sports had, not how Europeans percieved them.

Dissydesi said...

I don't like this, but I would, based on our grading sheet have t give them a 5 because they have everything except the POV

Pooh Bear said...

Charles..i too didnot not find a POV. But i think i did find an attempt of one. Um..the use of the documents was kinda weird. Like the whole slave and women's right thing was out of nowhere. I agree with Brian..so a 4

Pooh Bear said...

just kidding..no attempt of POV