Thursday, April 10, 2008

DBQ ESSAY C

What do you think this essay should get? Respond. Also, feel free to raise questions about parts of the essay (groups, thesis, POV analysis, analysis of documents, outside information, etc.) If you are responding to someone else's comment, be sure to make it clear who you are addressing.

26 comments:

Padiller said...

Did any one find the thesis for this essay?

Brian said...

I gave DBQ Essay C a 6. I thought it was comparable to Essay A,but its structure was definitely different (seperation of body paragraphs into different European countries).

Megahertz said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Pooh Bear said...

I gave this person a 2. I felt that this person did not meet hte reqirements to get more points. The thesis was poorly written and the grouping of the DBQ was questionalble. I wasn't able to judge if the grouping was correct or not since i need the question for the DBQ to determine that. The person did not even attempt to write any POV at all. Yea so that's what i think...

Megahertz said...

I gave it a 3?
I can't find a thesis anywhere, and therefore cannot find how it's supports the thesis.
I had trouble finding all three POV's too.

Can you point it out Briiiian?

Brian said...

Because of how they structured their arguement, their thesis is extended on from the initial paragraph, I think. In the actual thesis "statement," which I do think was kinda iffy, they said that Europeans in different areas perceived sports differently. This difference in perception was then explored in the body paragraphs independently country by country.

I think the thesis is there, but in an inconspicuous way.

mingthemerciless said...

Blogger Padiller said...

Did any one find the thesis for this essay?

April 10, 2008 9:47 AM

which one? a b c

Pooh Bear said...

Brian, you gave them a 6? I don't know..the person didn't even do a POV..the thesis was weird..it didn't answer the question...maybe i am just weird..

Megahertz said...

Well yeah I see that but it doesn't really say HOW they perceived it differently in the thesis, right?

Idk, it just doesn't seem "there" to me.

mingthemerciless said...

never mind i see it now

"DBQ ESSAY C"

Marie said...

I gave this essay a 3. I couldn't find the thesis, however they used a majority of the documents properly and had three explicit groups and their opinion on sports in their essay.

Zabe Thompson said...

Would they lose points for restating the question?
BUt I see a thesis in this one, it is the introduction paragraph. Possibly the the author did know how to explain the differences in the introduction.

I like concept the organization by countries because it shows literally, Europeans by nationality and how the veiws differed. However the author seemed to have run out of time to finish the final paragraph about Central and Soutehrn Europe.

Dissydesi said...

I found no thesis in this DBQ. They did have groups and their over all eassy answered the question. I give it a 3/4 because it uses the 9 documents, has 3 povs and answers the question. It fails only because there is no thesis that answers the question, only one that restates it.

Ashley said...

I gave the essay a 4. I thought that the thesis was poorly formed if there at all. This person simply restated the question like twice and that was the extent of the intro paragraph? I thought that it had 3 precise groups and had documents to support it. I also saw pov. This person used the author of each document to show why they would think that way whether it be by their status or motive for writing.

Master Liz said...

I gave Essay C a total score of 3. I couldn't find a thesis that answered the question and i only found one POV.

Marie said...

Brian YOU ARE WRONGGGG! ;0 RAWR!

Brian said...

So...I no longer give this a six because on a TECHNICALITY, you cannot scatter a thesis througout the paper.

Why Collegeboard is against elliptical writing...I don't know because elliptical writing can be some of the most elucidating writing there is.

=[

Pooh Bear said...

i guess the grouping was kinda iffy to me. But i guess you can count them as groups since they did answer the question later on in the paragraphs. Um..the only problem is the thesis...with that a 3 would be okay..for them

Dissydesi said...

I change my mind and give them a 5

Zabe Thompson said...

conspiracy againist the uniqueness of the human mind Brian.

That's why collegeboard is against against diverse forms of writing...

Or it is alot easier to grade the standard form of organization, so they don't allow for others.

Steph it up =] said...

I gave this person a 4 because they had no thesis and asnwered the question, but didn't explain the reason for their answer. They understood the documents and were able to organize them into correct groups. The thesis seemed to be spread out through the essay and never settled on one conclusion.

Marie said...

So I only found 2 POV...if anyone can point out the third I'll give them a 4.
"this document takes place shortly after the Berlin Olympics and diplomacy was more important than ever in the past WWI era. Hilter, in Germany, was becoming more affressive so Britain would need allies" this is after Doc 11.

"The government probably used sports to lure young men to join the army" this is after doc 6.

Megahertz said...

The POV for doc 11 I'm not fully getting. Explain it to me D:

Master Liz said...

i agree with megan!!
That doesn't sound like a POV to me..

mingthemerciless said...

DBQ:A

i would give this a 5 or 6 because the thesis did answer the question, then there is three groupings and a majority of the documents used. there was enough POV's, but the POV's were kind of there but at the same time not.

Anonymous said...

There was not a good thesis in this essay. I mean, like Brian said, it was sort of spread out throughout the essay, but the original thesis just sort of restated the question: "Europeans perceived sports differently from 1860 to 1940."

Not all of the documents supported the thesis.

I also could only find 2 legitimate POVs...

Therefore, I gave it a 3